NinSheetMusic Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  


NinSheetMusic is 13 years old!

Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Messages - Dudeman

Pages: [1] 2 3 ... 462
Forum Games / Re: Posts Against Humanity
« on: Today at 06:44:17 AM »
mikey is DQ'd for spelling ni wrong

Forum Games / Re: The NSM Guess-That-Melody Quiz!
« on: Today at 04:07:57 AM »
I just did as well. I couldn't see it at first, but then I saw it.
You couldn't see it? At this time of year, at this time of day, in this part of the country?

Oh. Well. Shit.


The Werewolf Game / Re: TWG 100th Anniversary: Dinner and a Show
« on: February 21, 2018, 08:35:30 PM »
Just posting to say that I won't have any time to post or be on Discord today until after the phase ends. I also have heavy suspicions on Brainy which have only been encouraged by his latest few posts, but I will keep my vote on THC.

Off-Topic / Re: Hall of Quotes
« on: February 21, 2018, 12:38:12 AM »
2/19/18 Mortantly (adv.)- M-Morty, we gotta *burp*, we gotta make a definition for t-this stupid *burp*, definition game, Morty.

I-I mean, it's really n-not that bad Rick, I don't know why you don't like it-

Because I don't need to use big, fancy words Morty! If I can explain something in three *burp* syllables or less, it means I've done my job, Morty!

A-Aaaaww geez Rick...

The Werewolf Game / Re: TWG 100th Anniversary: Dinner and a Show
« on: February 20, 2018, 10:44:38 PM »
Love that post, Olimar, really good summation. Nice digging on the Thicc situation; I don't really see a reason to lynch him if Mael's actually going to be coming in.

I'm dropping my suspicions of raeko for finally explaining her night 1 post. The reasoning makes sense to me, even if I do personally think some discussion and coordination is a good thing during the night. I agree with FA's first point that you could've been that elaborate in your original post, but w/e, that's out of the way now.

My biggest suspicions are on TZP, THC, and Brainy. FA, Olimar, Bubbles, and BDS seem fairly clean to me. I don't really have enough information to say a lot about anyone else. I'm keeping my vote on THC for the time being.

The Werewolf Game / Re: TWG 100th Anniversary: Dinner and a Show
« on: February 20, 2018, 05:32:17 AM »
Because my reasoning for swapping to davy is being called into question a lot lately, I'm going to post the relevant chat log where I ultimately made my decision. I'll admit I didn't articulate my reasoning very well in the topic here; when I posted, the Discord discussion had shifted slightly from "who's more wolfy" to "if we lynch a human, should we revive," so reviving was on my mind when I made the post. I did not swap to davy strictly because I'd want him revived over raeko; that's a ridiculous play. THC and davy were the two I was most suspicious of, so I wanted one of them confirmed. It was clear THC wasn't going to get lynched, so that was the main impetus for my swap to davy. FireArrow has admonished me in Discord for not just saying "I want to switch to davy because I want davy lynched more than THC" and thinking I needed more of a reason than that. I personally feel that some reasoning is better than no reasoning at all, but I'll admit talking about revives really wasn't the reasoning I was working with.
[6:35 PM] mastersuperfan: if davy is a wolf though it's going to bite us harder in the long run if we don't lynch him than if raeko is a wolf and we don't lynch her
[6:35 PM] Gerik: The thing about davy is he has already established multiple relationships
[6:36 PM] Gerik: So as the game goes on and we learn peoples colors we can use deductive logic to figure him out
[6:36 PM] Gerik: I.e. olimar being a wolf practically confirms davy is a human
[6:36 PM] Gerik: All the people trying super hard to lynch him are pracctically human if he ends up being a wolf
[6:38 PM] mastersuperfan: well I have 22 minutes left to make a decision
[6:38 PM] mastersuperfan: though it looks like raeko's going to get lynched either way
[6:39 PM] Ducleman🐺🚫: I can be convinced to swap to davy.
[6:40 PM] Ducleman🐺🚫: I still don't like THC, but he's less threatening if davy's a wolf.
[6:40 PM] Gerik: I probably could be too
[6:40 PM] mastersuperfan: it's already taking me a lot of effort to convince myself of anything lol
[6:40 PM] Gerik: but neither is going to be posting a defense so
[6:40 PM] Gerik: meh
[6:40 PM] Pearl: @Lkjhgfdsa_77  lol
[6:40 PM] mastersuperfan: idk my gut is not to lynch raeko
[6:40 PM] mastersuperfan: but davy being human if we lynch him would hurt
[6:41 PM] Ducleman🐺🚫: We have a reviver.
[6:41 PM] Lkjhgfdsa_77: yes
[6:41 PM] Gerik: @Pearl what are you responding to?
[6:41 PM] mastersuperfan: oh yes right
[6:41 PM] Ducleman🐺🚫: I of course don't want to blow the revive this early, but
[6:41 PM] Pearl: he's playing woof
[6:41 PM] Gerik: oh lol
[6:41 PM] Ducleman🐺🚫: davy's an experienced player, and if he can be confirmed human, reviving him isn't a bad move
[6:42 PM] Gerik: Well he'll just die again anyways
[6:42 PM] Ducleman🐺🚫: But of course we wanna revive the Brutal more than anyone else
[6:42 PM] Gerik: Revive only has three purposes this game:
[6:42 PM] mastersuperfan: but he could go ahead and set up that alliance that he was talking about
[6:42 PM] mastersuperfan: which I think would be helpful
[6:42 PM] Ducleman🐺🚫: I'm still not sold on the alliance
[6:42 PM] Gerik: Revive brutal, revive kjajit for one more item, revive random person to make an allaince
[6:42 PM] Ducleman🐺🚫: Who sends the information out?
[6:42 PM] Gerik: No one
[6:42 PM] mastersuperfan: it's a behind-the-scenes alliance
[6:42 PM] Ducleman🐺🚫: Alliance is good 'cause confirmed humans
[6:42 PM] mastersuperfan: where the specials are just in contact with each other
[6:42 PM] Ducleman🐺🚫: But who tells the humans not to lynch the alliance
[6:42 PM] Pearl: isnt the revive a one time use?
[6:43 PM] Gerik: It just won't happen naturally
[6:43 PM] Ducleman🐺🚫: Yes @Pearl
[6:43 PM] Gerik: with 4 or so humans knowing not to vote eachother
[6:43 PM] Gerik: And they can reveal last minute if needed
[6:43 PM] Ducleman🐺🚫: See that's the thing, if wolves pick up on that, they know who the specials are
[6:43 PM] mastersuperfan: as I did say earlier though
[6:43 PM] Gerik: counterclaims would instantly be spotted by other alliance memebers
[6:43 PM] mastersuperfan: it would take a lot of caution for the specials to avoid giving themselves away
[6:43 PM] mastersuperfan: ^^ yeah
[6:43 PM] mastersuperfan: actually that's probably harder than I thought it was at first
[6:43 PM] mastersuperfan: maybe the alliance isn't such a good idea
[6:44 PM] Gerik: The only issue with an alliance like I said before it somehow starting it without uniting them until counterclaims are sorted out
[6:44 PM] Ducleman🐺🚫: If you form a group of humans who are suddenly all supporting each other, that's a giant flag to the wolves
[6:44 PM] Gerik: But that can only happen if by the brutal human
[6:44 PM] mastersuperfan: if we're worried about the reviver getting wolfed early then using it to revive a human davy is not a bad use
[6:44 PM] mastersuperfan: better than reviving a human raeko I think
[6:44 PM] Ducleman🐺🚫: Oh absolutely better than reviving raeko
[6:45 PM] mastersuperfan: yes why'd I say I think there lol
[6:45 PM] Gerik: raeko is too inactive to do that with anyways lol
[6:45 PM] mastersuperfan: definitely is
[6:45 PM] Pearl: that's hoping davy isnt the reviver
[6:45 PM] Ducleman🐺🚫: So, raeko lynch in 15 minutes
[6:45 PM] mastersuperfan: ...that's true
[6:45 PM] Ducleman🐺🚫: Do I swap votes or no
[6:45 PM] mastersuperfan: I think I'm going to go with davy
[6:45 PM] Ducleman🐺🚫: That's a KitB
[6:45 PM] mastersuperfan: it would be 4 davy - 5 raeko?
[6:46 PM] mastersuperfan: BDS switched
[6:46 PM] Ducleman🐺🚫: oh I missed BDS
[6:46 PM] Pearl: I can unvote
[6:46 PM] mastersuperfan: if someone on raeko switches to BDS then we don't have a kitb
[6:46 PM] mastersuperfan: not BDS
[6:46 PM] mastersuperfan: davy
[6:47 PM] Pearl: a davy lynch does feel like the right thing to do
[6:47 PM] Pearl: and i was going to vote davy at one point as seen by my vote post
[6:47 PM] Pearl: so i'll switch
[6:47 PM] Ducleman🐺🚫: I'm swapping votes.
[6:48 PM] Ducleman🐺🚫: Cool @Pearl
[6:48 PM] Gerik: Dudeman
[6:48 PM] Gerik: A revive is only useful if we're trying to start an alliance
[6:49 PM] Gerik: Which you said you were against?
[6:49 PM] Gerik: Otherwise we have no reason to revive him unless he ends up being khajit or the brutal
[6:49 PM] Ducleman🐺🚫: Davy's a veteran, if he's human, I can trust him to make a good starting plan in the phase he has left alive
[6:50 PM] Gerik: That's a really poor reason to revive someone
[6:50 PM] Ducleman🐺🚫: Also I can't stop the alliance from happening, I just don't think it'll be all that useful
[6:50 PM] Ducleman🐺🚫: Since imo the wolves would be able to spot it pretty easy
[6:50 PM] Gerik: If we revived davy as a human
[6:50 PM] Pearl: Also @Gerik  E. Gadd had a regional comp Saturday so it makes sense why he would do this
[6:50 PM] Gerik: He would start an alliance
[6:50 PM] Ducleman🐺🚫: And no guardian means if one gets revealed, they're all dead pretty fast
[6:50 PM] Gerik: You think an alliance would harm us
[6:51 PM] Ducleman🐺🚫: Nah, I just think it won't do much good
[6:51 PM] Ducleman🐺🚫: Not the same as doing harm
[6:51 PM] Gerik: I'll post my consolidated thoughts in the thread
[6:51 PM] Gerik: I just think you're logic makes no sense
[6:51 PM] Ducleman🐺🚫: It doesn't make sense but if you're set on making it w/e
[6:51 PM] Gerik: your*
[6:51 PM] BlackDragonSlayer: It could harm if we put too much effort into the alliance and it turns out not to help.
[6:52 PM] Gerik: I'm not talking about his logic about an alliance
[6:52 PM] Gerik: his logic about lynching davy because he's a better revive target
[6:52 PM] Gerik: which if he's human, the only value in reviving him is to try and start an early allaince
[6:53 PM] Pearl: 7 minutes left i think
[6:54 PM] mastersuperfan: yes
[6:54 PM] mastersuperfan: *crosses fingers*
[6:55 PM] BlackDragonSlayer: 5 minutes left i think
[6:55 PM] Ducleman🐺🚫: Yep
[6:55 PM] BlackDragonSlayer: :P
[6:56 PM] Pearl: 4 minutes left
[6:57 PM] Ducleman🐺🚫: Well at any rate, I find davy's playing suspicious moreso than THC's so I'm still comfortable with this decision.
[6:57 PM] Pearl: 3
[6:57 PM] Ducleman🐺🚫: Insisting that the wolves hit Monika just seems odd
[6:57 PM] Ducleman🐺🚫: Like, it's NSM
[6:57 PM] Ducleman🐺🚫: Inactivity will always be a factor
[6:57 PM] BlackDragonSlayer: I miss the golden era of TWG...
[6:57 PM] mastersuperfan: inactivity's a possibility if all four wolves just suck
[6:57 PM] mastersuperfan: I just think it's more likely that they hit Monika
[6:58 PM] Pearl: 2
[6:58 PM] Ducleman🐺🚫: I think at this point, the thing we all agree on is that it probably wasn't an intentional decision
[6:58 PM] mastersuperfan: I seriously doubt it was
[6:58 PM] THC 🐺🚫: Yeah, that would really have no benefit
[6:58 PM] Ducleman🐺🚫: I don't see the advantage in that level of mindgame
[6:58 PM] Ducleman🐺🚫: Unless that's just what they want us to think!
[6:59 PM] Pearl: 1
[6:59 PM] THC 🐺🚫: Unless all the wolves suck at TWG
[6:59 PM] mastersuperfan: stop @Ducleman🐺🚫 you're hurting my brain

2/19/18 Mordently (adv.)- playing two adjacent notes in a negative, malicious, or damaging fashion

The Werewolf Game / Re: TWG 100th Anniversary: Dinner and a Show
« on: February 20, 2018, 04:23:52 AM »
Well, rip Tras, you did okay.

Just gonna get my THC vote out of the way now. If anyone needs me to explain my reasoning again, lemme know.

The Werewolf Game / Re: TWG 100th Anniversary: Dinner and a Show
« on: February 19, 2018, 08:02:17 PM »
Quote from: Bubbles link=topic=9869.msg394542#msg394542
also, this might be a real controversial thought, but I just realized it. How does an alliance work in a game with no guardian? Even if we unite the specials somehow, if they tried to work together to lynch someone it would just alert the wolves based on who's working together (even if they weren't outright with it, it wouldn't be that hard to see who is thinking the same thoughts and always voting for the same people). The Reviver doesn't need to work alongside anyone, since their only job is with the dead who have confirmed roleflips. I guess the seer could share their results, but that would lead to the same issues as above. Best case the Brutal Human could claim to the thread, but there would be no way to confirm that and it wouldn't stop them from getting marked by Monika. What little could be done with the alliance set up is overshadowed by the risk of the wolves connecting the dots and having a list of all the specials imo
This is exactly what I've been trying to say this whole time. I don't see how it's a safe play.

2/18/18 Gallade (n.)- a skillful glide over snow or ice in descending a mountain, as on elbow swords
take that, noc

The Werewolf Game / Re: TWG 100th Anniversary: Dinner and a Show
« on: February 19, 2018, 03:48:07 AM »
I'm swapping my vote to davy for reasons I discussed in Discord. In short, a dead human davy who we can revive is more valuable than a dead human raeko who we can revive. Also davy's more of a question mark to me than THC.

The Werewolf Game / Re: TWG 100th Anniversary: Dinner and a Show
« on: February 19, 2018, 01:49:40 AM »
I can't decide between Olimar and Davy either, and we still haven't heard that much of raeko (especially about her too early post), but I want to prevent an insta so I won't pu a third vote on her.
Insta's only happen when over half of all the players all vote on the same person. This is far from that.

The Werewolf Game / Re: TWG 100th Anniversary: Dinner and a Show
« on: February 19, 2018, 01:41:55 AM »
Errr, ok. You just seem to be repeating everything everyone else is saying about davy to save your own ass now.
I was rethinking my THC vote, but that's exactly what I realized too partway into thinking about it. I'm keeping my vote.

Pages: [1] 2 3 ... 462

Page created in 0.247 seconds with 21 queries.